Donor Communications: Old Dogs, New Tricks, and the Fallacy of Print-Only Donors

I’ve had just about enough of the excuse: “Well, you know, our older donors prefer print.”
It rolls off the tongue like gospel in boardrooms and strategy meetings across the nonprofit sector. It’s said with such confidence, as if carved into stone tablets handed down from the development gods. But here’s the thing: it’s not gospel. It’s not even accurate. It’s a lazy assumption dressed up as stewardship.
Let me be blunt. “Older people prefer print” is a fallacy.
And worse than that, it’s a stereotype that sells our donors short and undermines our ability to communicate with relevance and respect.
I’ve heard it used as a reason not to update communication methods, not to invest in better donor journeys, not to experiment with behavior-based touchpoints, not to digitize stewardship reports, not to clean up data systems. And to that, I say: enough. It’s time we stop using age as an excuse to avoid progress.
I think about my own parents: my mother logs into her MyChart health app to check her test results faster than her doctor can call her. She schedules appointments online, orders her medications through a portal, and FaceTimes me at the drop of a hat. And my father? He’s an email junkie! He manages his Social Security through a login. Checks stock quotes and reads the news digitally. He even sends me articles from websites I haven’t heard of, with commentary. They aren’t anomalies. They’re examples. They’re evidence that our assumptions about “older people” are dangerously outdated.
Let me ask you this: where exactly is the research proving this universal print preference among older donors? Because the data I’ve seen tells a more nuanced story. Yes, print still plays a role. Yes, there are donors who enjoy receiving tangible materials. But enjoying print and preferring only print are two very different things. One honors the channel; the other clings to a myth.
We need to stop confusing comfort with capability. Just because a donor appreciates receiving a printed holiday card doesn’t mean they aren’t also checking email multiple times a day. Just because they enjoy a physical annual report doesn’t mean they aren’t logging into their bank accounts, managing their healthcare online, or reading articles on an iPad. These are not people frozen in time. They’re living, breathing, human beings who’ve spent the last decades navigating and adapting to a digital transformation just like the rest of us.
And here’s the irony: the systems older adults interact with the most: Medicare, Social Security, healthcare portals have all gone digital. Not partially. Entirely. You cannot access your Medicare benefits without logging into a digital system. You cannot manage your Social Security without a password and a device. And our donors, even the “older” ones, are somehow managing to do this. Every single day. Without our help. So, explain to me again why they can’t read a stewardship report online or click on an impact video?
This stereotype that older donors are incapable or unwilling to engage digitally hurts everyone. It holds organizations back from modernizing. It narrows the scope of donor relations. It reinforces the idea that we can only move at the slowest pace of perceived comfort. And most insidiously, it infantilizes a generation that has already proven their resilience, their adaptability, and their intelligence.
If you want to talk about what older donors truly want, let’s talk about that. They want relevance. They want connection. They want to see their impact. They want communication that respects their intelligence and honors their generosity. And above all, they want to be treated like individuals, not categories.
The age of a donor should not be a weapon used to stall innovation.
And yet, I’ve watched entire stewardship strategies get stuck in the mud because someone insists “our older donors won’t like that.” Based on what? A hunch? A single anecdote? One letter from a donor in Florida who misses the paper newsletter? That’s not data. That’s fear. And fear is not a strategy.
Here’s what I’ve learned from years of working in this space: donors will follow you into the future if you give them a reason to. Honestly, they may already be there waiting for you. If the experience is meaningful. If it makes their life easier. If it tells them what they need to know, when they need to know it. So, don’t insult their intelligence by assuming they can’t navigate an emailed report or an interactive giving dashboard. Design it well, and they will use it. Tell the story well, and they will read it no matter the format.
Now, let me be clear. I’m not calling for the eradication of print media and communications. I’m not suggesting we go digital-only overnight. What I’m calling for is something much more radical: intentionality. If you’re going to print, do it because it enhances the experience, not because you’re afraid to do something new. If you’re going to send digital, make sure it’s designed with care and clarity, not just convenience. Meet the donor where they are, but first, make sure you’ve actually asked where that is. Don’t assume. Don’t stereotype. Don’t settle for the easiest narrative.
And for the love of all that is strategic, don’t let a donor’s birth year dictate their engagement journey.
Let their behavior do that.
The real danger here isn’t simply how we communicate, it’s what this assumption says about how we view our donors. It says we don’t believe they can evolve. That they don’t deserve new ideas. That we know better than they do about what they’ll engage with. That’s not stewardship. That’s arrogance.
I’ve worked with donors in their 70s, 80s, even 90s, who send me email feedback on PDFs, who forward donor stories to friends, and who Zoom into virtual events. I’ve also worked with 30-something donors who ignore every email and only respond to a handwritten note. Age is not the determinant. Behavior is.
We can’t afford to keep designing our strategies around assumptions. Not in an era where retention is slipping and attention is fractured. Not when donors are more sophisticated, more connected, and more discerning than ever. The best donor relations professionals I know don’t cling to myths. They ask better questions. They test. They iterate. They listen. They meet each donor with curiosity, not conclusions. So, the next time someone in your organization says, “But our older donors prefer print,” I want you to pause. Breathe. And then ask: do they really? Or are we just afraid of building something better?
Because if my parents can manage their healthcare, finances, and travel plans online, then your donors can too. Let’s stop using age as a crutch and start designing with excellence for all generations.
Written by Lynne Wester





